I thought I'd jot down my ideas about the recent OPERA superluminal neutrinos at CERN. In case you hadn't heard, the experiment found neutrinos that (as far as they can tell) move slightly faster than the speed of light.
If correct, this is a big deal, since "faster than light" in one reference frame means "back in time" in another. Being able to send information back in time would lead to implausible, crazy new technology.
My best guess as to what's going on is that there’s a systematic error in OPERA we haven’t found yet.
My second best guess: light actually travels a little slower than c,
at least around Earth. This could be due to interaction with some
unknown particle cloud that’s consistently uniform and has a refractive
index of 1.0002.
No, this isn’t the aether, and this isn’t experimentally contradicted
by the fact that the speed of light doesn’t change as the Earth changes
velocity through this field. Just as the speed of light through a
moving glass rod isn’t greater or smaller than through a still glass rod
(neglecting dispersion, which comes into play as the Doppler-shifted
frequency of light causes n to change slightly), moving through this
weakly-interacting particle background doesn’t change the observed
velocity of light, unless the medium is dispersive. A good assumption
would be the medium isn't noticeably dispersive: whatever transitions the light interacts with are of such
high energy that photons we generate all look about the same, and
dispersion isn’t measurable.
Heck, the medium could even be dark matter. This hypothesis solves a
bunch of problems, like why the neutrinos from the 1987A supernova were
coincident with (and not before) the photons. Under this hypothesis,
the photons traveling though deep interstellar space would not be slowed
by the presumably rarefied dark matter there.
Like I said, my money’s still on the possibility that there’s a
systematic experimental error at OPERA. However, I find the idea of a
vacuum/dark matter refractive index a lot more palatable than particles
that violate causality. I haven’t yet heard a good reason to discredit
this idea, so I thought I’d post it.
Background: I have an honours physics undergrad degree, but I’m now a
neuroscientist. None of my colleagues are capable of evaluating this
idea; if it’s rubbish please don’t hesitate to point out why.
Monday, October 31, 2011
Monday, July 26, 2010
News Flash: Rocks Too Deadly for Schoolkids?
Greetings, daredevils.
I just happened upon a great Forbes article about the insane lengths the Consumer Product Safety Commission goes to keep dangerous toys like plain old rocks out of the hands of schoolchildren. I'd write more, but in some ways res ipsi locutor, and I have to get to work too.
Via BoingBoing.
I just happened upon a great Forbes article about the insane lengths the Consumer Product Safety Commission goes to keep dangerous toys like plain old rocks out of the hands of schoolchildren. I'd write more, but in some ways res ipsi locutor, and I have to get to work too.
Via BoingBoing.
Saturday, July 10, 2010
Give Parents a Chance: Part 1: diaper diatribe
Greetings, potential p1 generation.
It's been a long time since I posted to this blog. My life's been irrevocably improved by a nine-month-old daughter, and I've changed cities as well. I bet you might have thought I was gone for good, but here I am, back with another cold, hard numerical look at our decisions.
Today, I'm going to write a post I wish I'd read a few months before coming a dad; this may evolve into a short series.
Over-educated parents get weird about a whole lot of things and one of them is diapers. It's practically taboo for a Ph.D.-toting couple like us to use throw-away diapers that will sit in a landfill for eternity. We've bowed to social pressure and bought a g-diaper system, complete with multiple reusable covers (that need a lot of laundering nonetheless) and flushable inserts.
The joke's on us, however, since cloth diapers on the whole are not any more environmentally friendly than disposables. Laundering cloth diapers in soap and hot water takes as much energy and releases as many chemicals into the environment as having disposable diapers.
The three big advantages of disposable over cloth are:
In conclusion, let me absolve any prospective parent out there (I can do this now that I'm officially ordained - another story) of any disposable-related guilt. Disposables are awesome technology - use 'em with a clear conscience.
It's been a long time since I posted to this blog. My life's been irrevocably improved by a nine-month-old daughter, and I've changed cities as well. I bet you might have thought I was gone for good, but here I am, back with another cold, hard numerical look at our decisions.
Today, I'm going to write a post I wish I'd read a few months before coming a dad; this may evolve into a short series.
Over-educated parents get weird about a whole lot of things and one of them is diapers. It's practically taboo for a Ph.D.-toting couple like us to use throw-away diapers that will sit in a landfill for eternity. We've bowed to social pressure and bought a g-diaper system, complete with multiple reusable covers (that need a lot of laundering nonetheless) and flushable inserts.
The joke's on us, however, since cloth diapers on the whole are not any more environmentally friendly than disposables. Laundering cloth diapers in soap and hot water takes as much energy and releases as many chemicals into the environment as having disposable diapers.
The three big advantages of disposable over cloth are:
- Cost (disposables are about half as expensive)
- Baby's skin (disposables these days can keep 'em dry through the night)
- Time (it's much faster to change a disposable diaper than a cloth one, and when you're only getting 4 hours of sleep a night for the first three months, even an extra 5 minutes 8 times a day is really appreciated)
In conclusion, let me absolve any prospective parent out there (I can do this now that I'm officially ordained - another story) of any disposable-related guilt. Disposables are awesome technology - use 'em with a clear conscience.
Sunday, December 30, 2007
Getting a D in Health
Greetings, indoor, computer-reader.

The Sunbathing Ape
It's natural for us to feel drawn to amazing photographs of sun-soaked landscapes. We humans evolved as mostly-naked, outdoorsy folks in sunny Africa. Although the cultures (and to some degree the genes) of migrating peoples have done what they can to adapt to more polar environments, if you dig at all deep into our biology you'll see we still aren't fine-tuned to live indoor, boreal lives.
One of the biologically unmet expectations humans in the USA and Canada experience is low sun exposure, leading to Vitamin D deficiency. This article in the Globe and Mail suggests that Canadians typically have about one third of optimal concentrations of vitamin D in their bloodstream.
What's D Good For?
Until recently, it was thought that the major effect of vitamin D deficiency was rickets. Since (last time I checked) rickets wasn't an endemic problem to North Americans, vitamin D was seen as being a non-issue; the mandated additions of D and A to dairy products seemed to be sufficient to keep bone formation normal in children.
However, vitamin D has more functions than merely the regulation of bone density. It's also an important chemical precursor to a lot of important cellular signaling mechanisms: not having sufficient vitamin D is the equivalent of trying to run a government when there's a shortage of notepads to write on.
D and Cancer Rates
One of the worst consequences of screwing up chemical messages is to impede natural anti-cancer cellular mechanisms. Does our D-prived culture result in fact in increased cancer rates? The only way to know for sure is with a double-blind experiment where groups are given vitamin D and placebos at random, and to track prevalence of cancers in the two groups. That's exactly what this study did, and what they found is almost unbelievable. Giving 1.5g supplemental Calcium with 1100 IU per day (about 3 liters of milk worth, but the study used pills) decreased cancer rates by 77% after one year.
Great moons of Neptune! That's a huge decrease! The cautious part of me finds it hard to believe that one factor could be responsible for over half of cancers, and to be fair the study tracked only 1200 women over 4 years, and thus wasn't able to notice enough cases of cancer to have really tight confidence intervals: the range of cancer decreases still consistent with the study is 91%-40% 19 times out of 20. Still, I've started feeding vitamin D to my wife as well as taking it, if not daily, than at least often.
Public Health Consequences
Suppose the study's numbers bear up, and that about half of cancers could be prevented by 1100 IU of vitamin D per day. Would it be a good policy for health insurers (or friendly socialist governments like Canada's) to simply hand out vitamin D supplements? It looks like the cost of vitamin D is pretty much nothing: this bottle of 250 pills (almost a year's supply) with 1000 IU of vitamin D is only $10. On the flipside, the annual cancer rate in the US is 1 in 200. If that could be halved by the D supplement, and if treatment costs on average $40 000, that's an expected savings of $100 per year. Pay one dollar into prevention, get 10 out in unneeded treatment. (Oh, then there's the whole increase in lifespan and quality of life issue too.)
Last Word
I suppose the cautious policy approach would be to conduct a larger study to figure out where within the wide confidence interval the truth lies. However, I'm inclined to start ramping up vitamin D production and consumption programs, maybe even with heavy subsidy by governments, HMOs or otherwise. Let's get a D in health.

The Sunbathing Ape
It's natural for us to feel drawn to amazing photographs of sun-soaked landscapes. We humans evolved as mostly-naked, outdoorsy folks in sunny Africa. Although the cultures (and to some degree the genes) of migrating peoples have done what they can to adapt to more polar environments, if you dig at all deep into our biology you'll see we still aren't fine-tuned to live indoor, boreal lives.
One of the biologically unmet expectations humans in the USA and Canada experience is low sun exposure, leading to Vitamin D deficiency. This article in the Globe and Mail suggests that Canadians typically have about one third of optimal concentrations of vitamin D in their bloodstream.
What's D Good For?
Until recently, it was thought that the major effect of vitamin D deficiency was rickets. Since (last time I checked) rickets wasn't an endemic problem to North Americans, vitamin D was seen as being a non-issue; the mandated additions of D and A to dairy products seemed to be sufficient to keep bone formation normal in children.
However, vitamin D has more functions than merely the regulation of bone density. It's also an important chemical precursor to a lot of important cellular signaling mechanisms: not having sufficient vitamin D is the equivalent of trying to run a government when there's a shortage of notepads to write on.
D and Cancer Rates
One of the worst consequences of screwing up chemical messages is to impede natural anti-cancer cellular mechanisms. Does our D-prived culture result in fact in increased cancer rates? The only way to know for sure is with a double-blind experiment where groups are given vitamin D and placebos at random, and to track prevalence of cancers in the two groups. That's exactly what this study did, and what they found is almost unbelievable. Giving 1.5g supplemental Calcium with 1100 IU per day (about 3 liters of milk worth, but the study used pills) decreased cancer rates by 77% after one year.
Great moons of Neptune! That's a huge decrease! The cautious part of me finds it hard to believe that one factor could be responsible for over half of cancers, and to be fair the study tracked only 1200 women over 4 years, and thus wasn't able to notice enough cases of cancer to have really tight confidence intervals: the range of cancer decreases still consistent with the study is 91%-40% 19 times out of 20. Still, I've started feeding vitamin D to my wife as well as taking it, if not daily, than at least often.
Public Health Consequences
Suppose the study's numbers bear up, and that about half of cancers could be prevented by 1100 IU of vitamin D per day. Would it be a good policy for health insurers (or friendly socialist governments like Canada's) to simply hand out vitamin D supplements? It looks like the cost of vitamin D is pretty much nothing: this bottle of 250 pills (almost a year's supply) with 1000 IU of vitamin D is only $10. On the flipside, the annual cancer rate in the US is 1 in 200. If that could be halved by the D supplement, and if treatment costs on average $40 000, that's an expected savings of $100 per year. Pay one dollar into prevention, get 10 out in unneeded treatment. (Oh, then there's the whole increase in lifespan and quality of life issue too.)
Last Word
I suppose the cautious policy approach would be to conduct a larger study to figure out where within the wide confidence interval the truth lies. However, I'm inclined to start ramping up vitamin D production and consumption programs, maybe even with heavy subsidy by governments, HMOs or otherwise. Let's get a D in health.
Thursday, September 27, 2007
Editing Miranda
Greetings, lawmakers.
When was the last time democracy had a makeover? Arguably, there hasn't been a big change to the way Americans govern themselves for 200 years. Well, except maybe allowing black people to vote in 1969 and women in 1920; OK maybe there have been some 20th-century improvements in terms of who can vote. However, in almost every one of today's democracies, the only governmental venue where the electorate at large expresses their views is at the polling station.
The Checkbox Menace
Yes or no questions can distort your position. Don't believe me? Try:
Elections so far allow only really coarse-grained opinions to pass from the people to the law. Politicians don't have a monopoly on good policy ideas, ergo there are some great ideas floating around which will never see the light of day as long as votes are the only way to influence laws.
Until now, this restriction of opinions has been necessary to keep procedures streamlined: there's been no way of having an intelligent exchange of opinions with 200 million voters. Until now?
Kiwi Wiki
That's right, the New Zealand government has opened up a wiki site where they let you draft the law. Its power so far is only advisory (I think that's wise, at least for now), but it allows good ideas and intelligent debate to percolate up from the people without the government doing a thing (apart from setting up MediaWiki or some such).
I'll be interested to see what comes of the New Zealand experiment. Does anyone below care to register their predictions as to if this will be fabulous or a flop?
Keep on wikin',
LeDopore
When was the last time democracy had a makeover? Arguably, there hasn't been a big change to the way Americans govern themselves for 200 years. Well, except maybe allowing black people to vote in 1969 and women in 1920; OK maybe there have been some 20th-century improvements in terms of who can vote. However, in almost every one of today's democracies, the only governmental venue where the electorate at large expresses their views is at the polling station.
The Checkbox Menace
Yes or no questions can distort your position. Don't believe me? Try:
Elections so far allow only really coarse-grained opinions to pass from the people to the law. Politicians don't have a monopoly on good policy ideas, ergo there are some great ideas floating around which will never see the light of day as long as votes are the only way to influence laws.
Until now, this restriction of opinions has been necessary to keep procedures streamlined: there's been no way of having an intelligent exchange of opinions with 200 million voters. Until now?
Kiwi Wiki
That's right, the New Zealand government has opened up a wiki site where they let you draft the law. Its power so far is only advisory (I think that's wise, at least for now), but it allows good ideas and intelligent debate to percolate up from the people without the government doing a thing (apart from setting up MediaWiki or some such).
I'll be interested to see what comes of the New Zealand experiment. Does anyone below care to register their predictions as to if this will be fabulous or a flop?
Keep on wikin',
LeDopore
Labels:
21st century capitalism,
future-proof policy,
government,
law,
politics
Thursday, September 20, 2007
Rail Blues
Greetings, Takers of the A-train,
Last night I went to a show in the big city. As you know, I don't own a car, so I took a subway car back, and noticed how very odd it was that about 100 rich patrons waited with me for over 20 minutes for a train. (My metropolitan area has notoriously infrequent trains, especially at night.) It got me wondering: how crazy is it (financially) to run trains infrequently at night?
Extra Costs
It's easy to say "Let's just run trains every minute," but the whole reason why public transit systems work is that many people going the same way can use just one vehicle and driver. Let's figure out the cost of splitting one infrequent but long subway trains into two shorter trains.
If the run lasts two hours and the driver costs $40/hour (including overhead, training, etc.) the personnel expense is $80. The necessary force (hence electricity cost) of pushing an additional train front through the air can be calculated using:
F = .5 A D p v^2,
where A is the area of the train front, D is a drag coefficient (usually about .25 for aerodynamic shapes), p is the density of the medium and v is the speed. Using A D = 4 m^2, p = 2kg/m^3, v = 20 m/s, electricity costs $.15/kWh and the distance traveled is 100 km, we see the extra energy costs is a measly $7. Let's round up and say an extra $100 would be needed to run an extra train.
Extra Benefits
So, how much shorter a commute would there be if an extra train came? The trains come every 24 minutes, and by the time a train came last night there were over 100 people waiting at my station and over 100 at the next station (the two busiest, mind you); let's lowball the estimate and say 250 people would be able to catch a train on average 6 minutes sooner if train frequency were doubled. Doubling train frequency means 25 commuter hours would have been saved at a cost of $100 to the system: $.40 per passenger or $4/hour of passenger time saved.
However, increasing service might increase ridership, so it's possible that the extra train would (at least partially) pay for itself. Increasing ridership eases burdens on parking and roads too; public transit is overall a good bargain.
Summary
It's time commuters got vocal about being willing to pay a fair amount for their time that gets wasted by sluggish schedules. I wish we'd get a consistent metric of how much our time is worth, and use it to make policy decisions. Check out my post on machine wages for equivalent cost-time comparisons; this concept may evolve into a wiki page soon.
Keep on track!
LeDopore
Last night I went to a show in the big city. As you know, I don't own a car, so I took a subway car back, and noticed how very odd it was that about 100 rich patrons waited with me for over 20 minutes for a train. (My metropolitan area has notoriously infrequent trains, especially at night.) It got me wondering: how crazy is it (financially) to run trains infrequently at night?
Extra Costs
It's easy to say "Let's just run trains every minute," but the whole reason why public transit systems work is that many people going the same way can use just one vehicle and driver. Let's figure out the cost of splitting one infrequent but long subway trains into two shorter trains.
If the run lasts two hours and the driver costs $40/hour (including overhead, training, etc.) the personnel expense is $80. The necessary force (hence electricity cost) of pushing an additional train front through the air can be calculated using:
F = .5 A D p v^2,
where A is the area of the train front, D is a drag coefficient (usually about .25 for aerodynamic shapes), p is the density of the medium and v is the speed. Using A D = 4 m^2, p = 2kg/m^3, v = 20 m/s, electricity costs $.15/kWh and the distance traveled is 100 km, we see the extra energy costs is a measly $7. Let's round up and say an extra $100 would be needed to run an extra train.
Extra Benefits
So, how much shorter a commute would there be if an extra train came? The trains come every 24 minutes, and by the time a train came last night there were over 100 people waiting at my station and over 100 at the next station (the two busiest, mind you); let's lowball the estimate and say 250 people would be able to catch a train on average 6 minutes sooner if train frequency were doubled. Doubling train frequency means 25 commuter hours would have been saved at a cost of $100 to the system: $.40 per passenger or $4/hour of passenger time saved.
However, increasing service might increase ridership, so it's possible that the extra train would (at least partially) pay for itself. Increasing ridership eases burdens on parking and roads too; public transit is overall a good bargain.
Summary
It's time commuters got vocal about being willing to pay a fair amount for their time that gets wasted by sluggish schedules. I wish we'd get a consistent metric of how much our time is worth, and use it to make policy decisions. Check out my post on machine wages for equivalent cost-time comparisons; this concept may evolve into a wiki page soon.
Keep on track!
LeDopore
Thursday, September 13, 2007
Life in the Slow Lane
Greetings, road warriors.
This post is about commuting; specifically why I refuse to do long commutes. I don't really understand why people put up with long commuting. Some of my coworkers get up at 4 AM to get to work on time (8 AM), twice a day wasting in traffic more time than it takes to travel by train from Rome to Naples. Where do I start with the problems here? That kind of squandering of human life is so egregious that I don't even know where to start to try to attack it: res ipsa loquitor! If that res still isn't very loquacious, read on!
In an earlier post, I quantified how much you pay labor-saving machines for each hour of chores they save you; here I'm going to figure out how much you're paying yourself to live in a cheap neighborhood and commute to a good job.
Tinned Nation
On average last year, Americans spent 50 minutes per work day commuting to and from their jobs; mostly in a sitting position within oversized metallic cans on wheels. However, like the aforementioned coworkers, over 3.4 million Americans spent more than three hours per day commuting to work. If these extreme commuters value their time at $25/hour and work 20 days per month, they're spending $1500 of their time every month for the privilege of living where it's cheap. Unless housing is drastically more expensive where they work, it's just not worth their time.
Leisure sucker
Commuting is more than just a monetary problem, however: the less free time you have the more precious it becomes. If you're awake 16 hours a day, work 8 hours and spend 2 hours keeping the household together that leaves just 6 hours of discretionary free time per day. If three hours is sucked up in commuting, you have half the time to pursue self-development.
Greeks to the Rescue?
Aristotle thought the best division of waking hours was to spend 6 hours working, 6 hours resting and 6 hours pursuing some leisured activity: being creative and exercising parts of your body and intellect for the shear joy of it. The 8-hour work day already overbalances this ancient ideal; why tip it further into job-is-everything territory?
Personally I'm dismayed with the fact that the remainder of peoples' time usually has to go towards wakeful resting (like watching the tube), and not the active creation of interesting life, tradition and culture. I want life to be more participatory: we should be having a good time with the freeboard that going to work gives, if the work itself isn't fun (a harsh reality I'm trying to avoid).
Staying Un-Canned
What are some ways to keep our commuting hours down? How about the following for a start;
leave comments if you have more ideas.
Take care, and stay out those cars as much as possible!
LeDopore
Hold infinity in the palm of your hand-- William Blake, Auguries of Innocence
And eternity in an hour.
This post is about commuting; specifically why I refuse to do long commutes. I don't really understand why people put up with long commuting. Some of my coworkers get up at 4 AM to get to work on time (8 AM), twice a day wasting in traffic more time than it takes to travel by train from Rome to Naples. Where do I start with the problems here? That kind of squandering of human life is so egregious that I don't even know where to start to try to attack it: res ipsa loquitor! If that res still isn't very loquacious, read on!
In an earlier post, I quantified how much you pay labor-saving machines for each hour of chores they save you; here I'm going to figure out how much you're paying yourself to live in a cheap neighborhood and commute to a good job.
Tinned Nation
On average last year, Americans spent 50 minutes per work day commuting to and from their jobs; mostly in a sitting position within oversized metallic cans on wheels. However, like the aforementioned coworkers, over 3.4 million Americans spent more than three hours per day commuting to work. If these extreme commuters value their time at $25/hour and work 20 days per month, they're spending $1500 of their time every month for the privilege of living where it's cheap. Unless housing is drastically more expensive where they work, it's just not worth their time.
Leisure sucker
Commuting is more than just a monetary problem, however: the less free time you have the more precious it becomes. If you're awake 16 hours a day, work 8 hours and spend 2 hours keeping the household together that leaves just 6 hours of discretionary free time per day. If three hours is sucked up in commuting, you have half the time to pursue self-development.
Greeks to the Rescue?
Aristotle thought the best division of waking hours was to spend 6 hours working, 6 hours resting and 6 hours pursuing some leisured activity: being creative and exercising parts of your body and intellect for the shear joy of it. The 8-hour work day already overbalances this ancient ideal; why tip it further into job-is-everything territory?
Personally I'm dismayed with the fact that the remainder of peoples' time usually has to go towards wakeful resting (like watching the tube), and not the active creation of interesting life, tradition and culture. I want life to be more participatory: we should be having a good time with the freeboard that going to work gives, if the work itself isn't fun (a harsh reality I'm trying to avoid).
Staying Un-Canned
What are some ways to keep our commuting hours down? How about the following for a start;
leave comments if you have more ideas.
- Arrange to spend one day a week telecommuting (if possible)
- Use a home office
- Rent an apartment close to your job (and price out the time cost of your commute if you live far from your job - you might consider moving then)
- Live/work arrangements are also great
Take care, and stay out those cars as much as possible!
LeDopore
Labels:
economics,
motor vehicles,
philosophy,
technology
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)